Respected firearms scholar and researcher John Lott posted a blog entry on Fox News where he too responds to the rigged "experiment" produced by 20/20. I am happy to say that Prof. Lott and I came to similar conclusions about the nature and tone of the program. He illustrates how 20/20's methods were poor and their summations biased (and perhaps disingenuous):Dr. Ignatius Piazza, of the acclaimed Front Sight firearms training school, also responded to the 20/20 story. While he uses the ill prepared students as a plug to advocate training at his schools, he clearly states what 20/20 casually overlooked:The show ends with this claim:
“If you are wondering where are all the studies about the effectiveness of guns used by ordinary Americans for self-defense, well keep searching, we could not find one reliable study and the ones we found were contradictory.”
Yet, “contradictory” is an overstatement. There have been 26 peer-reviewed studies published by criminologists and economists in academic journals and university presses. Most of these studies find large drops in crime. Some find no change, but not a single one shows an increase in crime.
Even though you may...fall into the category of the 99% of people who are not yet mentally or physically prepared to win a gun fight, the chances are your opponent is not trained either — so having a gun and some training is still better than not having a gun!More importantly, Piazza provides a nice list of articles and videos about concealed carry holders defending themselves and stopping violent crime. Here is that list:
- Concealed Weapons Permit Holder Stops Bank Robbery
- Off Duty Copy Gets Jumped but Protects Himself with Handgun
- 69-Year-Old Man Shoots Intruder
- CCW Gun Fighter Shoots Two Armed Assailants
- Grandmother Holds Bugler at Gun Point
- Surviving a Gun in Your Face
- Armed Robber stopped by CCW Holder
- Armed Watch Maker Stops Multiple Robberies
- Armed Citizen - Nashville, Tennessee
- Armed Homeowner Shoots Robbers During Daytime Invasion (AZ)
- Woman With Shotgun Kills Rapist in Self-Defense (MO)
- Robber Killed by Clerk
- Pizza Shop Owner Shoots Armed Robber (OH)
- Houston Self Defense Shooting CCW
- Clerk Shoots Crook
- Holdup victim kills gunman in Manheim
- Armed Citizen - Buffalo, New York
- Armed Citizen - Kinsey, Alabama
- Gunman killed in robbery attempt
- Armed Citizen - Canton, Michigan
- Brave store clerk shoots back
- Armed School Teacher Shoots Armed Invader in Self-Defense (FL)
- Man who shot robber at AA gathering
No comments:
Post a Comment